museum illustration heritage stories

How museum illustration brings
heritage stories to life

Historical illustration involves a balance between research and imagination. But where does the evidence end and artistic interpretation begin?

Introduction

Museums and heritage organisations often have stories to tell about people, places and events that existed long before photography. Sometimes there are detailed records and surviving images. At other times, we know something happened but have very little idea what the people involved looked like or what their lives were like.

Illustration offers a way to explore these gaps, but it also raises questions about how much we can reasonably invent. When drawing the past, I find myself moving between what the evidence tells us and what we can imagine might have been.

The line between historical accuracy and imagination

One of the things I find interesting about museum illustration is that it can show things we have no photographic evidence of: objects that no longer exist, buildings that have disappeared, people whose faces we don’t know and events that happened long before photography was invented.

When I start a project, I ask my clients for as much information as they can provide. I then carry out my own research, both visual and written, to understand the context. This might include looking at contemporary photographs, paintings, clothing, architecture, objects and other details that help inform the drawing.

I’m an illustrator rather than a historian, so I don’t assume that I can independently determine whether every piece of information I’ve found is historically reliable. I share my research with clients and ask them to check the illustrations for historical accuracy.

But even with thorough research, there are often things we simply cannot know. What colour were someone’s clothes? What expression might they have had? What were they doing when nobody was recording it? These are the points where interpretation comes in.

When the evidence isn’t there

For the Health Histories project, I had to imagine what a woman might have looked like had she not spent twenty years in an asylum. There was no photograph showing her at that point in her life, so the illustration wasn’t simply a matter of reproducing an existing image. I had to consider what could reasonably be inferred from the available information and create a possible version of the person she might have been.

The distinction is important. The illustration wasn’t claiming that this was exactly what she looked like. It was offering one possible way of imagining her life. I’ve faced a similar question when creating an illustrated interpretation board for an archaeological project. The aim was to help people living on a new housing development connect with the archaeological history of the site.

betty huffer illustration by kati lacey

Creating characters from the past might have been an effective way to make that connection, but it would also have meant giving viewers a very specific image of what those people might have looked like. We decided to take a different direction.

There isn’t necessarily one right answer. Much depends on the subject, the available evidence and the purpose of the illustration. But I think it’s important to recognise when we’re making an informed suggestion rather than depicting something we know to be true.

 

Bringing historical people to life

Not every project involves reconstructing people whose appearance is unknown. Sometimes there are photographs, portraits and other visual records to work from, but there is still room for interpretation.

At Kelmscott Manor, I worked on illustrations showing members of the Morris family around the time they moved to the Manor. The brief was to portray real people in a playful way without making the illustrations feel childish. The colour palette needed to sit within the world of William Morris, and the drawings were kept relatively simple rather than becoming highly detailed historical reconstructions.

We used their activities to give the illustrations personality. May Morris is shown riding on the roof of the estate, her sister is reading beside the river, William Morris is cutting the famous hedge in the garden and May’s mother is picking apples.

I particularly like the illustration of May Morris. In many photographs she appears rather stern, whereas in the drawing she is smiling. This was a joint decision with the project team. The activity itself was historically grounded, but the expression allowed us to imagine a little more of her personality.

Where the evidence ends

I think this is one of the more interesting aspects of working with museums and heritage organisations. Illustration involves making decisions, and not every decision can be supported by a photograph or a written record.

Sometimes the available evidence gives us enough to make an informed interpretation. At other times, it makes more sense to leave something open rather than create an image that might be mistaken for historical fact.

The important thing is to understand the difference between what we know and what we are imagining. That distinction doesn’t have to prevent us from using our imagination, but it should inform how we approach the work.

kati lacey avatar animation

Working on interpretation or a non-fiction book?

I illustrate interpretation panels, exhibitions, learning resources and non-fiction books, researched with the people who know the subject.